Twin Peaks made its debut in 1990 as a cultural phenomenon, captivating audiences with its whodunit storyline and charming FBI agent Dale Cooper. The show’s creator, David Lynch, and writer-producer Mark Frost wove a unique vision that merged genres, tones, and styles, forever changing the television landscape.
Twenty-five years later, Twin Peaks: The Return arrived in 2017, marking a third season with 18 episodes, all directed by Lynch. With complete creative autonomy, the duo executed their distinct vision, resulting in strange yet compelling TV. Agent Cooper is trapped in the supernatural Black Lodge, working to escape while his doppelganger plots to prevent Bob’s return.
The Return features multiple subplots, including the Log Lady’s quest for justice and a murder in Buckhorn, South Dakota, which draws FBI attention. The show moves between story arcs, timelines, and dimensions, with surreal sequences that leave more questions than answers.
MacLachlan’s performance shines as Cooper’s duplicate, Dougie, brings a new dynamic to the series. The Return surpasses its predecessor, season two, in coherence, thanks to Lynch’s bold direction. Appreciation lies in the emotional resonance, with standout performances from returning characters and newcomers like Robert Forster and Naomi Watts.
Twin Peaks’ appeal stems from its small, simple moments that evoke fear, sadness, or joy. The show balances violence, cruelty, and humor with heart-wrenching final episodes and ambiguous endings. Lynch’s narrative bookending creates a sense of satisfaction despite devastation. With all its surrealism, Twin Peaks remains true to life’s unpredictable vicissitudes.
Twin Peaks: The Return is streaming on Paramount+ (Australia, UK, US).
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2025/jan/08/twin-peaks-the-return-david-lynch-masterpiece-reboot