**
Sherlock Holmes spin-off *Watson* has been overshadowed by its own confused plot, with critics calling it “nonsensical” and forcing viewers to juggle two unrelated storylines. The pilot, which premiered on January 26 in the US, struggled to make sense of itself, leaving fans wondering if it was meant as a standalone medical mystery or part of a larger Sherlock Holmes universe. Despite promising premise and chaotic writing, the show failed to deliver coherence, leaving viewers feeling lost.
The attempt to blend Watson’s medical procedural elements with his past patient dramas resulted in disjointed storytelling, as noted by *USA Today* and *Variety*. Both outlets highlighted how the show tried too hard to fit into Sherlock’s legacy while neglecting its own identity. critic Kelly Lawler compared it to “CSI” on steroids, lacking depth and failings that modern writing often face.
Fans online echoed these sentiments, with many calling it another forgettable medical drama like *Elementary*. One viewer likened it to *Brilliant Minds*, suggesting it lacks the charm of past shows. Director Martin Freeman even quipped about the show “not being fun” in context of Sherlock’s other roles, a line that was later clarified as just him being honest.
The latest Sherlock Holmes spin-off remains a perplexing mix of ambition and overreach, with no clear path forward after its rocky premiere.
Source: https://www.nme.com/news/tv/critics-blast-unhinged-sherlock-holmes-spin-off-watson-3832221