The UK government is pushing Apple to create a backdoor in its end-to-end encrypted data, giving authorities access to iCloud communications. This move undermines the fundamental right to private spaces and communications.
Apple’s Advanced Data Protection feature turns on encryption for backups and other data stored in iCloud, making it impossible for even Apple to access that information. However, law enforcement has previously exploited a loophole in this system. If Apple complies with the UK demand, users may consider disabling cloud backups altogether.
Implementing a backdoor compromises security and puts users at risk of hacking, identity theft, and fraud. Such systems can be easily exploited by repressive governments worldwide to monitor protests and dissenters’ communications. Many companies, including Google, use similar end-to-end encryption in their backup options.
The US has taken a different stance on encryption, with top cybersecurity officials advocating for its continued use. Apple’s resistance to the UK demand is crucial, as there is no legal mechanism to force such a rule in the US. The implications of this ruling will be felt globally, especially if Apple is prohibited from warning users about compromised data protection.
Source: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2025/02/uks-demands-apple-break-encryption-emergency-us-all