US Army veteran and war researcher John Spencer says he does not believe there is a genocide in Gaza, despite allegations made by Israeli human rights groups and other critics. Spencer, chair of urban warfare studies at West Point, has been embedded with the Israeli Defense Forces and interviewed senior officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Spencer cites the Genocide Convention’s definition as the basis for his conclusion, arguing that it depends on intent. He points to statements by Israeli officials that emphasize their goal is not to harm civilians but rather Hamas militants. However, critics argue that these actions have resulted in immense destruction and significant loss of life, with tens of thousands of people dead.
Spencer acknowledges a food shortage in Gaza, but disputes the notion that Israel’s efforts were ineffective in providing aid. He suggests that the true issue lies with Hamas’ refusal to cooperate with humanitarian efforts. Spencer also criticizes critics for overstating the severity of the situation and implying that every bad event is a war crime.
The Israeli government has dismissed allegations of genocide, with Netanyahu stating that his country is fighting a “just and moral” war. The US President Trump’s comments on the matter highlight the ongoing debate over the conflict in Gaza.
Source: https://www.npr.org/2025/07/29/nx-s1-5478643/war-scholar-discusses-why-he-does-not-think-there-is-a-genocide-in-gaza