Linux creator Linus Torvalds has rejected a set of proposed changes for the RISC-V architecture in the upcoming Linux 6.17 kernel, citing tardiness and poor quality. The patches were submitted by RISC-V maintainer Palmer Dabbelt just days before the merge window close. Torvalds described parts of the code as “garbage” due to its late submission and failure to meet quality thresholds. This decision highlights the Linux kernel’s strict development process, which prioritizes stability and security.
The rejection may delay advancements for RISC-V users and developers, who were relying on new features like improved firmware interfaces or vulnerability reporting enhancements. Industry observers note that RISC-V’s rapid evolution clashes with the methodical pace of kernel integration. The setback is a result of RISC-V’s maturation pains, including performance issues on available hardware.
The rejection serves as a reminder of Torvalds’ gatekeeping role in Linux, where quality trumps haste. While the RISC-V team has an opportunity to refine their submissions for the next cycle, balancing innovation with kernel rigor will be key to its long-term success. The community debates whether this rejection stems purely from process or deeper concerns about RISC-V’s readiness for prime time.
With the Linux 6.17 kernel release delayed, RISC-V users can expect updates in Linux 6.18. Rocky Linux recently added official RISC-V support, signaling growing interest in the architecture. However, competitors like ARM continue to dominate mobile and server markets, making it essential for RISC-V to balance innovation with kernel rigor for long-term success.
Source: https://www.webpronews.com/linus-torvalds-rejects-garbage-risc-v-patches-for-linux-6-17