This week’s NXT episode was marred by inconsistency and confusion. Jacy Jayne took another pin from Oba Femi, solidifying her status as a beatable champion. However, this lack of competitiveness makes it difficult to invest in the character.
Meanwhile, DarkState continued to be a mystery, with no clear direction or motivation. They seem more like a nuisance than a legitimate threat to the show. The faction’s fluid motivations and inconsistent appearances make it hard to care about their storyline.
The only notable moment came from Chelsea Green, who stood up for her fellow Canadian Ethan Page against Alba Fyre. This segment was well-executed, showcasing Tyra Mae Steele’s abilities and creating a connection between her and Tavion Heights’ representative.
On the positive side, Lash Legend impressed in her match against Nia Jax, showing strength and resilience in the face of adversity. Jasper Troy received an underwhelming video package that failed to make an impact.
The main issue with NXT right now is its inability to create a cohesive narrative. With too many storylines and factions, it’s difficult for the show to focus on one thing. The constant changes and lack of momentum make it hard to invest in the characters or care about their stories.
As Geno noted, NXT seems to be struggling to find direction with its talent. It’s unclear how they plan to fix this inconsistency, but it’s essential that they do so to restore the show’s credibility.
Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/wwe/376522/nxt-recap-reactions-aug-12-2025-too-much-of-everything-else