Dune: Prophecy is a complex show that struggles to balance its numerous characters, plots, and universe-building. The season 1 finale approaches, presenting two potential paths for the series. Desmond Hart’s destiny holds the key, with one possibility seeing him as the proto-Kwisatz Haderach, the inspiration behind the Bene Gesserit’s quest for a powerful leader.
This straightforward path would simplify the show’s narrative and risk shrinking its universe. A more ambitious approach, dubbed the “midi-chlorians path,” would allow the series to expand its world-building by introducing unanswered questions and unanswerable mysteries. This route would require Dune: Prophecy to diverge from its current storytelling style, potentially opening up a larger, stranger universe.
Dune’s success lies in its ability to balance messiness with ambition. The original book is a masterpiece of sci-fi world-building, despite being well-connected in ways that may seem limiting now. To replicate this success, the show must create frayed edges and introduce new complexities. The season 1 finale will be crucial in determining Dune: Prophecy’s direction, with a big, messy, and ambitious conclusion needed to justify its continued exploration of the universe’s mysteries.
Source: https://www.polygon.com/opinion/496634/dune-prophecy-finale-theories-season-1-desmond-hart