A long-standing debate has erupted over when to celebrate Eid-ul-Fitr in Saudi Arabia, with UK experts challenging the country’s claim of witnessing a Shawwal crescent on March 30. The Islamic calendar relies on actual moon sightings, but modern astronomical calculations allow for precise predictions.
Astronomers say it was impossible to see a new crescent so soon after a solar eclipse on March 29, casting doubt on Saudi Arabia’s announcement. However, this is not an isolated incident, and “phantom moonsightings” are common in the region. These claims often align with preprinted calendars rather than actual visibility.
For Muslims in the UK, the New Crescent Society confirms that Ramadan’s 29th day will fall on Sunday, March 30, making Eid easily visible. This means many will celebrate on Monday, March 31, alongside mosques following Morocco and South Africa. However, those adhering to Saudi Arabia’s declaration will observe Eid on Sunday, March 30.
The debate highlights the tension between tradition and modern knowledge in determining Islamic dates. Until a global consensus is reached, Muslims worldwide will navigate these differences with patience and faith. At its core, Eid-ul-Fitr remains a celebration of joy, gratitude, and community, transcending specific dates.
Source: https://www.hindustantimes.com/lifestyle/festivals/eid-2025-uk-experts-challenge-saudi-s-impossible-shawwal-crescent-sighting-eid-ul-fitr-in-ksa-on-sunday-march-31-101743262257490.html