The recent selection of Jacob Misiorowski to the National League All-Star team has sparked outrage among fans and players alike. The 23-year-old flame-throwing rookie, who has only made five big-league starts, was chosen as a roster replacement for an injured pitcher. This move has led many to question the decision, particularly from the Phillies, who feel that more deserving candidates should have been selected.
Phillies shortstop Trea Turner expressed his frustration with the selection, saying “What a joke… That’s f— terrible.” Turner believes Misiorowski has no business being an All-Star given his limited experience. While Misiorowski’s impressive performances in four of his five outings cannot be denied, others argue that pitchers Cristopher Sánchez and Ranger Suárez, who have been excellent but not receiving the same level of recognition, are more deserving.
Sánchez, a 2.59 ERA pitcher in 18 starts, was unable to pitch in the game due to his scheduled start on Sunday. Suárez declined an invitation to join the All-Star team because he wanted to be available to pitch for his team. The controversy highlights the optics of selecting players based on marketability rather than talent.
Misiorowski’s selection is not unique, as many pitchers have stepped aside from the game due to scheduling conflicts or rest reasons. However, some argue that this move could negatively impact the sport and its ratings.
The controversy surrounding Misiorowski’s All-Star selection serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by Major League Baseball in selecting deserving players for the game.
Source: https://eu.jsonline.com/story/sports/mlb/brewers/2025/07/12/one-mlb-team-isnt-thrilled-with-misiorowski-all-star-selection/84772530007