The Netflix algorithm is currently favoring UK content with moonier eyes than usual, following the success of “The Crown” and its spin-off, “Bridgerton.” This trend can be seen in the new romantic comedy “My Oxford Year,” which premiered last month. The film tells the story of Anna, a working-class New Yorker who defers her job to study at Oxford for a year.
Despite initial expectations of a ribald comedy, director Iain Morris has opted for a sentimental and light-hearted approach, focusing on Anna’s experiences as an American in England. The film boasts some historical beauty, thanks to its on-location shooting, but it lacks the complexity and depth required to elevate it beyond a typical Netflix rom-com.
Anna’s romance with Jamie, a foppish gent played by Corey Mylchreest, is predictable and lacking in tension. Their meet-cute is laughably convoluted, and their relationship suffers from a lack of conflict, leading to a romance that feels beige rather than exciting. The film attempts to add some spice, but it ultimately falls flat.
The reveal in the film’s dramatic turn is underwhelming, feeling like a predictable twist that fails to surprise. This swerve overshadows any potentially engaging elements of class differences, artistic vs commercial choices, and navigating life between two continents.
Competent director Iain Morris is outshone by the lackluster script from Allison Burnett and Melissa Osborne. Despite being better suited for the role, Sofia Carson’s performance feels indistinctive and lacks magnetism to carry the film. Corey Mylchreest shows promise in his character, but a sharper script could elevate him further.
As a passive Netflix viewer, “My Oxford Year” is an underwhelming experience that fails to deliver the emotional depth required to leave a lasting impression. With so much more potential in this territory, it’s disappointing to see a film that relies on formula rather than taking risks and exploring bigger themes.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2025/aug/01/my-oxford-year-review-netflix