Saudi Arabia’s tradition of announcing Eid al-Fitr on a date that may not align with astronomical observations has sparked controversy once again. As Ramadan draws to a close, many Muslims around the world are eager to celebrate, but Saudi authorities have announced that Eid will fall on Sunday, March 30.
Astronomers say it is impossible to see the crescent moon on Saturday, when many Muslims typically look for its appearance. The Umm al-Qura calendar, used by Saudi Arabia, pre-dates lunar visibility and often produces results that defy scientific accuracy.
Critics argue that this practice perpetuates confusion and division within Muslim communities worldwide. In the UK, a divided community has long celebrated Eid on different days due to local moon sighting practices. However, many British Muslims are now seeking unity through local sightings.
Imad Ahmed, founder of the New Crescent Society, aims to bring an end to this division by promoting a unified Islamic calendar for Britain. “We don’t need to outsource moon sighting,” he explained. “And the younger generation of Muslims are interested in the notion of unity and an end to division.”
While Saudi Arabia’s pre-calculated Eid may seem convenient, experts warn that it can lead to confusion among Muslim communities worldwide. The practice highlights the importance of transparency and clarity in Islamic practices.
As Ramadan comes to a close, many Muslims will be eagerly awaiting news of Eid. But with Saudi Arabia’s announcement, it remains uncertain whether this year’s celebration will follow astronomical observations or pre-determined dates.
Source: https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/eid-2025-does-saudi-arabia-report-impossible-moonsightings