When compiling the rankings, experts consulted with over 40 coaches and staffers across the country, acknowledging that their opinions varied. Debates arose on quarterbacks near the top, such as Clemson’s Cade Klubnik and LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier. However, after a thorough evaluation, the top spot belonged to Klubnik, thanks to his strong deep ball throwing ability and solid athleticism.
Rising star Arch Manning was also given high praise, despite limited playing time. Scouts attribute his potential to his size, athleticism, arm strength, accuracy, and intangibles. However, concerns about his competition played a role in ranking him lower.
The top three Big 12 quarterbacks – Arizona State’s Sam Leavitt, TCU’s Josh Hoover, and Baylor’s Sawyer Robertson – garnered significant attention from coaches. Leavitt was deemed the total package with the highest ceiling, while Hoover is the best pure passer of the bunch.
Notable newcomers include Nico Iamaleava, Julian Sayin, Dante Moore, and Demond Williams. While some show promising potential, others face tougher challenges due to limited playing experience or surrounding talent.
Ultimately, these rankings aim to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the top FBS starting quarterbacks for the upcoming season.
Source: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6494976/2025/07/16/college-football-quarterback-tiers-debates-manning-iamaleava